Too Much, Not Enough: The Impossible Expectations Placed on Women
(Reading time – 10 minutes)
Short on time? Here’s the two-minute version
Women and girls are surrounded by contradictory expectations.
Be intelligent – but not a show-off. Be ambitious – but not intimidating. Look attractive – but do not appear to try too hard. Care for others – but maintain good boundaries. Be confident – but remain modest and likeable.
This is sometimes described as a double bind: a situation in which the demands are incompatible, meaning you can be criticised whichever one you meet. The problem is not simply that women are failing to find the right balance. Often, the “right” balance does not exist.
Girls begin absorbing these messages remarkably early. Research has found that, by the age of six, girls were less likely than boys to associate members of their own gender with being “really, really smart.” These expectations then follow women into adulthood, into workplaces, relationships, parenting, appearance, caring responsibilities and social media.
I know this tightrope personally as well as professionally.
Depending on whom you ask, I could be described as one of the most caring people in the world, or as an absolute bitch. For years, I found it almost intolerable when someone disliked me or held a version of me that felt unfair. I believed that if I explained myself properly, anticipated everyone’s needs and tried hard enough, I could correct their perception.
Instead, I tied myself in knots.
Eventually, I realised that I can listen, reflect, apologise, repair and take responsibility for my behaviour, but I cannot control the final version of me that exists in somebody else’s mind.
This can be particularly exhausting for women with diagnosed or suspected ADHD. Many become highly skilled at overpreparing, monitoring reactions and compensating so that nobody sees how much effort everyday functioning requires. From the outside, it looks like competence. On the inside, it can feel like never being allowed to stop performing.
The answer is not to stop caring about other people. It is to stop making universal approval the price of being yourself.
When you feel caught between competing expectations, ask:
- What / who’s impossible rule am I trying to obey?
- What actually matters to me here?
- What would one small action consistent with my values look like?
- What discomfort, such as guilt, uncertainty or disapproval, might I need to be willing to tolerate?
You will not be everything everyone expects. None of us can be.
The more useful question is: What kind of woman do I choose to be?
Too Much, Not Enough: The Impossible Expectations Placed on Women
Recently, my teenage daughter was having a difficult week. As we talked, frustration spilled into a remarkably perceptive rant about the rules girls are somehow expected to follow.
You have to be intelligent, but not so intelligent that you seem like a show-off or make other people feel intimidated.
You must not be considered unattractive, but you cannot look as though you are trying too hard. Wear too much make-up, and you will be judged for that too.
You should not be too thin. You certainly must not be too big. Whatever your body looks like, it seems to be available for public discussion.
The details change between school corridors, workplaces, families and social media, but the structure remains the same:
Be enough, but never so much that your existence makes somebody else uncomfortable.
My first response was honest: “Welcome to womanhood. This part of it sucks.”
I did not mean that she should accept it or make herself smaller. I meant: You are not imagining this. You have noticed something real, and noticing it gives you choices.
These are other people’s expectations. If the rules contradict one another, no version of you can satisfy them all. The question therefore cannot be, “How do I finally get this right?” It has to become, “What matters to me? What kind of person do I want to be?”
I told her that even her dad’s and my expectations should not be her ultimate guide. She disagreed; our opinion matters deeply to her, and I am glad it does. But my longer-term hope is not that she becomes brilliant at following our script. It is that she learns to recognise her own values and use them as a compass.
Why the Barbie speech made so many women cry
The conversation took me back to America Ferrera’s now-famous monologue as Gloria in Barbie. Gloria names the contradictions: be successful but always likeable; lead but never be bossy; look beautiful without admitting to trying; care for others without becoming tired or needy yourself.
When I watched that scene in the cinema with my best friend, I had tears in my eyes. I am fairly certain I was not the only woman there blinking through damp eyes in the dark.
The speech gave language to an old problem. Ferrera later described it as the “impossible assignment of being all things to all people”. Sometimes recognition itself is emotional. There is relief in hearing: No wonder you are exhausted. The assignment was never achievable.
The psychological double bind: when every answer can be marked wrong
Psychologists often use the term double bind for situations in which a person receives incompatible demands and can be penalised whichever demand they meet.
At work, women are expected to show leadership confidence while remaining warm, modest and accommodating. Experimental studies found that successful women in traditionally male roles were liked less than equally successful men. Other research found that self-promotion could increase perceptions of women’s competence while carrying social and hireability costs.
“I must demonstrate my value without looking full of myself” is therefore not always imagined insecurity; it can reflect a real, anticipated penalty. This is why “Just be more confident” is inadequate advice.
Girls learn the rules early
My daughter’s observations also reminded me how young girls are when they begin absorbing ideas about intelligence, ambition, beauty and visibility.
In one influential series of studies, girls as young as six were less likely than boys to associate their own gender with being “really, really smart” and became less interested in activities described as being for exceptionally clever children. Cultural ideas about who is allowed to be “brilliant” can begin shaping self-belief remarkably early.
Appearance brings another calculation. Adolescence makes peer belonging more salient, while social media supplies unrealistic, idealised images, comparison and quantifiable approval. Reviews link appearance-focused use with body dissatisfaction and disordered-eating symptoms, although supportive adults, schools and media literacy can be protective.
A girl can therefore be told to love herself while repeatedly receiving the message that her face and body are projects for improvement, and that trying too visibly to improve them is vain. Again, there is no reliably correct answer.
The rules follow us into adulthood
The school corridor eventually becomes a workplace, a family WhatsApp group, a leadership meeting or the school-gate conversation. The wording changes; the tightrope often remains.
Be ambitious, but do not neglect your family. Be an attentive parent, but do not let parenthood affect your performance.
Set boundaries, but do not be difficult. Ask for help, but remain effortlessly capable.
Age naturally, but do not “let yourself go”. Invest in your appearance, but do not appear vain or afraid of ageing.
I know this tightrope from the inside too
I am not writing only as a psychologist observing this pattern from a safe clinical distance. I have been caught by it too. Depending on whom you ask, I could be described as one of the most caring people in the world, or as an absolute bitch. To some, I am loving, soft and gentle; to others, aggressive, difficult or simply too much. People in my life hold profoundly different versions of me.
For a long time, I found that almost intolerable. The people pleaser in me believed that if I explained myself properly, anticipated everyone’s needs, remained agreeable and tried harder, I could correct any perception I believed was unfair. Instead, I wrapped myself in knots. Being fully present for one person meant being unavailable to another. Speaking honestly could make me “too much”; staying quiet could mean I had not done enough. Sometimes, the harder I tried to change somebody’s view, the more distressed and disconnected from myself I became, and the worse things became.
Eventually, I had to accept that people do not see us through a neutral lens. They see us through their own experiences, needs, wounds, expectations and the role we occupy in their story. That does not make every criticism wrong or remove my responsibility for my impact. I can listen, examine my behaviour, apologise, repair and act with integrity. But I cannot control the final version of me that exists in somebody else’s mind.
I also recognise many ADHD traits in myself, although I have not pursued a formal diagnosis. Looking back through that lens, I can see the energy I spent compensating, overpreparing, monitoring reactions and trying to prevent criticism before it arrived.
The turning point was not deciding that I no longer cared. I care deeply. It was releasing myself from responsibility for managing everyone’s perception of me, and recognising that I cannot care about everything and everyone equally without harming myself. My time, attention and energy are finite, so I must choose where they go.
I no longer aim to be acceptable to everybody. I want to be a decent person, act with integrity, love the people who matter, do work I believe in and live a good life as best I can. I will not do that perfectly, and that is rather the point.
Why this can be especially exhausting for women with ADHD traits
For women with diagnosed or suspected ADHD, the demand to appear organised, calm, reliable and consistently productive can add another layer of strain. ADHD in girls and women is more likely to be overlooked when difficulties are less disruptive or are hidden by coping strategies. Gendered expectations can make forgetfulness, impulsivity or disorganisation feel like failures not only of functioning, but of femininity.
Many high-achieving women become exceptionally skilled at compensating: overpreparing, double-checking, staying late, rehearsing conversations and building elaborate systems so nobody sees the effort ordinary functioning requires. From the outside, this looks like competence. From the inside, it can feel like never being allowed to stop performing; high functioning but high burden.
Your values are a compass, not another performance standard
In Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, values describe how we want to show up. Psychological flexibility means moving towards what matters, even when difficult thoughts and feelings come with us.
Values do not promise that nobody will judge you. They help you decide whose judgement gets to steer.
When you notice yourself twisting into knots, try asking:
- What rule am I trying to obey, and is it even possible to satisfy?
- What matters to me here; perhaps courage, kindness, health, connection or self-respect?
- What would one small values-consistent action look like?
State your view. Rest before everything is finished. Ask for the reasonable adjustment. - What discomfort am I willing to carry?
Guilt, uncertainty or disapproval do not automatically mean that a choice is wrong.
Values must not become another impossible rule: Now I must be perfectly authentic and never care what anyone thinks. We are social beings; belonging matters. The task is not to become immune to other people’s opinions, but less governed by them.
What I hope my daughter remembers
I cannot remove every contradictory message my daughter will receive or stop the world from commenting on women’s bodies, choices, voices, parenting, ambition and age.
But I can help her name what is happening.
I can remind her that an impossible standard is not evidence of a personal inadequacy.
I hope she learns earlier than I did that being misread can hurt, without becoming an emergency she must fix. I can be curious about who she is becoming, rather than requiring her to become a version of me. And I can keep returning her to the question I also need to ask myself:
If it is impossible to be everything everybody expects, what kind of woman do I choose to be?
That will not make the tightrope disappear. But it may help us step off it more often.
Gentle call to action
If you look capable on the outside but feel overwhelmed, depleted or never quite good enough inside, you do not have to wait until everything falls apart before seeking support. This can be especially important if diagnosed or suspected ADHD has led you to rely on perfectionism, overpreparation or people-pleasing.
Psychological therapy or ADHD-informed coaching can help you understand the rules you have been living by, separate your values from other people’s expectations and build ways of working and living that are more sustainable.
[Enquiry or discovery-call link]
Sources and further reading
- Attoe, D. E., & Climie, E. A. (2023). Miss. Diagnosis: A systematic review of ADHD in adult women. Journal of Attention Disorders, 27(7), 645–657.
- Bian, L., Leslie, S.-J., & Cimpian, A. (2017). Gender stereotypes about intellectual ability emerge early and influence children’s interests. Science, 355(6323), 389–391.
- Dane, A., & Bhatia, K. (2023). The social media diet: A scoping review of social media, body image and eating disorders among young people. PLOS Global Public Health, 3(3), e0001091.
- Heilman, M. E., Wallen, A. S., Fuchs, D., & Tamkins, M. M. (2004). Penalties for success: Reactions to women who succeed at male gender-typed tasks. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89(3), 416–427.
- Macri, J. A., & Rogge, R. D. (2024). Examining domains of psychological flexibility and inflexibility as treatment mechanisms in ACT. Clinical Psychology Review, 110, 102432.
- Department for Work and Pensions. (2026). Family Resources Survey: financial year 2024 to 2025.
- Ringrow, H. (2026). The impossibility of being a woman: Gendered expectations and rhetorical appeals in Barbie. Iperstoria, 27, 160–180.
- Rudman, L. A. (1998). Self-promotion as a risk factor for women. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74(3), 629–645.
- Vincente-Benito, I., & Ramírez-Durán, M. del V. (2023). Influence of social media use on body image and well-being among adolescents and young adults. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing and Mental Health Services, 61(12), 11–18.
- Young, S. et al. (2020). Females with ADHD: An expert consensus statement taking a lifespan approach. BMC Psychiatry, 20, 404.

