When the news becomes part of the harm
ADHD, disability and the responsibility that comes with a headline
(Approx. 9-minute read)
Short on time? Here are the key points
A headline is only part of the story. Reporting can mix evidence, interpretation and opinion. It helps to check what the original source actually says.
Negative stories grab our attention. Fear and outrage can draw us in, but that doesn’t make a story accurate or useful.
With influence comes responsibility. Journalists, influencers and professionals, including me as a psychologist, need to consider how their words affect people.
People deserve dignity and privacy. Seeking support, enjoying life or being visible online should not make someone a target for humiliation.
Before sharing, pause. Is it true? Is it kind? Is it useful? And why am I passing it on?
You can care and still take a break. Being selective about what you watch and read can protect your wellbeing. You don’t have to engage with every upsetting story.
We deserve reporting that helps us understand one another, with evidence, nuance and compassion.
Recently, I have found myself getting angry at the news
Particularly at the way ADHD, hidden disabilities and people seeking support are being discussed. I keep coming back to the same question: what responsibility comes with telling a story about someone else’s life?
The final report of the government-commissioned review led by Professor Peter Fonagy has now been published. I have not yet read it in full, and I want to do that before offering a considered response. So far, I have been listening to some of the advocates discussing it and noticing how it is being presented.
What concerns me is how quickly a conversation about assessment, unmet need and struggling services can become a conversation about whether people seeking help deserve our suspicion.
When the emphasis shifts towards people’s supposed motives for seeking a diagnosis, or suggestions that they are simply looking for financial support, I wonder what happens to the people reading those stories.
The person who has spent years wondering why everyday life feels so difficult. The parent trying to get their child understood. The adult who appears capable while privately struggling to hold everything together.
What do they hear?
Do they hear that their difficulties deserve careful assessment? Or that asking for help might make them a target?
The report and the story told about it
There is an important distinction between what a report says and the story someone constructs around it.
The Fonagy review’s executive summary distinguishes underlying population prevalence from recorded diagnoses and demand for assessment. It describes ADHD population prevalence as broadly stable or only modestly increased, while acknowledging substantial gaps in current data. It also discusses underdiagnosis, misdiagnosis and overdiagnosis, without establishing that overdiagnosis is occurring at scale. Its assessment of the current system is deeply critical.[1]
Those distinctions matter. More recorded diagnoses do not, on their own, tell us why the numbers have risen. Uncertainty deserves to be explained, rather than squeezed out of the headline.
As I read the full report, I may agree with some conclusions and question others. For now, my concern is the way these conversations are being framed, and the human consequences of that framing.
I am grateful to the advocates doing the painstaking work of checking claims, explaining evidence and challenging harmful coverage. That work matters. Alongside it, I think we need a conversation about the coverage itself.
What are we asking journalism to do?
Good journalism helps us understand the world. It investigates, questions power, exposes wrongdoing and brings neglected experiences into view.
That can involve uncomfortable questions about healthcare, public spending and the quality of services. Compassion should strengthen that scrutiny by keeping the people affected visible within it.
I want reporting that asks hard questions and takes care with the answers.
Who is being invited to speak? What evidence supports the interpretation? What uncertainty has been left out? Is an individual story being used to imply something about an entire group?
The Editors’ Code used by IPSO-regulated publications already requires care over accuracy, including headlines, and a clear distinction between fact, comment and conjecture. It also addresses privacy and the justification for intrusion in the public interest.[2]
These principles are a starting point. I think we should also ask what a piece of reporting contributes to public understanding, and whether its language unnecessarily humiliates the people involved.
With great power comes great responsibility
There is a familiar line, popularised through Spider-Man, that captures something central to this for me: “With great power comes great responsibility.”
When people listen to you, your words carry weight. That applies to mainstream media, influencers and anyone with a public platform. It also applies to me.
As a Psychologist, I know that my professional title brings a degree of credibility before someone has even read what I have written. People may place more trust in what I say because of my qualifications. I take that seriously.
When I put something into a public space, I try to think carefully about the evidence behind it, the limits of what I know and how it might land with someone reading it. Could the wording leave someone feeling ashamed? Could it reinforce a misconception? Have I made room for experiences that differ from my own?
I will not always get that right. But I see being willing to reflect, clarify and correct myself as part of the responsibility that comes with being trusted.
That is why I want to read the full report before offering a considered response. I can acknowledge my reaction to the coverage while being clear about what I have and have not reviewed.
And it is why I feel so strongly about the care taken by organisations whose reach is far greater than mine. The ability to shape how people understand themselves and one another carries a responsibility to consider the consequences.
Why the negative stories pull us in
As a Psychologist, I am interested in why certain stories are so difficult to look away from.
One part of the explanation is negativity bias: our tendency, in many circumstances, to give greater attention or weight to negative information. Threat, conflict and the possibility of wrongdoing can be particularly compelling.
A large study of headline experiments on the website Upworthy found that negative wording increased clicks. For a headline of average length, each additional negative word was associated with a 2.3% increase in the click-through rate.[3]
That is a finding from one particular news environment, rather than a universal rule about every reader or publication. But it illustrates a tension: the wording that attracts attention may do little to deepen understanding.
I think we need to recognise that commercial tension when we consume news. A story can capture us because it makes us frightened or furious. The strength of that reaction does not establish the quality of its evidence.
What are you feeding your mind?
Years ago, a supervisor encouraged me to think about what I was feeding my mind.
At the time, my clinical work included supporting people who had experienced rape and sexual assault. Alongside that, I was watching distressing news coverage and the programme 13 Reasons Why.
I began to notice how anxious and hypervigilant I felt.
My supervisor’s question helped me recognise the cumulative weight of what I was taking in. The work mattered deeply to me. But I also needed to consider what I was adding around it, and whether I was giving myself enough space to look after myself.
Research offers some support for that concern. In one experimental study, participants who watched a negatively framed television news bulletin experienced increases in anxious and sad mood, and greater catastrophising about a personal worry. The study examined short-term responses under experimental conditions; it cannot tell us exactly how any individual will respond to everyday news use.[4]
For me, becoming more selective made a difference.
For quite some time now, I have generally chosen not to watch the news routinely. I choose more carefully when and how I engage, and I feel happier as a result.
I still care. I still speak up about things that matter to me. I also recognise that my capacity has limits.
A person’s private life is not automatically public property
Another part of this conversation troubles me: the appetite for looking through someone’s private life to decide whether they are worthy of sympathy or support.
There can be legitimate public-interest reasons to investigate someone’s conduct. Exposing wrongdoing and holding powerful people accountable are essential functions of journalism.
But curiosity alone is a poor justification for intrusion.
Before sharing private details, I think we should be able to explain their relevance. What do they establish? What public interest do they serve? Is the intrusion proportionate?
I am particularly uneasy when fragments of a disabled person’s life become a public test of whether their difficulties are real.
A photograph, an enjoyable activity or an apparent success gives us a fragment of someone’s experience. It does not give us the whole of their daily life, the effort behind it or what happens afterwards.
Being visible online should not require someone to surrender every boundary.
Three filters before we pass it on
There is a story commonly attributed to Socrates about putting information through three filters before sharing it: is it true, is it good or kind, and is it useful?
I am treating that as a reflective story, rather than a verified historical quotation. The questions themselves are worth considering.
Is it true? Have I checked the original source? Am I repeating a finding, an interpretation or an allegation?
Is it kind? Does the language preserve the person’s dignity? Could the same legitimate point be made without ridicule or humiliation?
Is it useful? Does sharing this help people understand, make an informed decision or address a problem?
Truthful reporting sometimes causes distress. Important investigations can make people deeply uncomfortable. Kindness cannot mean avoiding every difficult truth.
For me, these questions encourage us to examine both the purpose and the manner of what we share.
I would add one more: why am I passing this on?
That applies to journalists, influencers, advocates and to me.
Reading with questions, choosing with care
News contains reporting, analysis, opinion and editorial choices. We need to know which we are reading.
A useful habit is to ask what has been established and what has been inferred. Follow the link to the report where possible. Look for the qualifications that may have disappeared from the headline. Compare how different outlets describe the same evidence.
It is also reasonable to consider an outlet’s ownership, funding and declared political position. These are questions to investigate, rather than reasons to assume that every story has a hidden motive.
The same care belongs on social media. Agreement with a message does not remove the need to check it.
And we can notice what happens to us while we read. Am I becoming informed? Am I becoming increasingly distressed? Is there an action I want to take, or am I repeatedly exposing myself to something I cannot resolve tonight?
Sometimes I will challenge a claim. Sometimes I will support the person already doing that work. Sometimes I will close the app.
We need people who have the capacity to keep asking questions. We also need room for people to rest.
We deserve more care with the story
The recent coverage has left me questioning the health of our media as well as the health of our services.
When I find myself thinking that our media is broken, I am thinking about what happens when attention becomes more valuable than understanding, and people’s lives become material for outrage.
There are journalists doing careful, compassionate and necessary work. I want more of that work to shape the conversation.
We can disagree about policy, diagnosis and public spending while retaining curiosity about the people affected. We can acknowledge uncertainty and still take suffering seriously. We can make room for difference without turning it into a reason for suspicion.
A headline reaches people who may already be wondering whether they are allowed to ask for help.
I want us to remember them when we decide how to tell the story.
Sources
- Department of Health and Social Care (2026). Independent review into mental health conditions, ADHD and autism: executive summary. This review applies to England.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/independent-review-into-mental-health-conditions-adhd-and-autism-final-report/independent-review-into-mental-health-conditions-adhd-and-autism-executive-summary - Independent Press Standards Organisation. The Editors’ Code of Practice. Applies to subscribing publications; it is not the regulatory code for all UK media.
https://www.ipso.co.uk/editors-code-of-practice/ - Robertson, C. E., Pröllochs, N., Schwarzenegger, K., Pärnamets, P., Van Bavel, J. J., & Feuerriegel, S. (2023). Negativity drives online news consumption. Nature Human Behaviour, 7, 812–822.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-023-01538-4 - Johnston, W. M., & Davey, G. C. L. (1997). The psychological impact of negative TV news bulletins: The catastrophizing of personal worries. British Journal of Psychology, 88, 85–91.
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8295.1997.tb02622.x

